Ayumi in SLT = oh, another GaGa copy?

[Yumsushi]

Originally Posted by BanaCherry

What? Have you heard sono de light speed english version and Can't take my eyes off you? She have a pretty decent english, and I think her lyrics are decent.

So that's 2 songs out of how many that don't make any sense? Maybe you should visit her solo work.

@FuNsTyLe
Believe it or not, those of us that didn't think Gaga have perfectly healthy vision. Gaga didn't invent face paint, Fashion, nor vogue-like hand movements so why should anyone associate these things with just her?

[Crystal_Ageha]

^ Yeah, believe it or not, there actually are people in the world who don't know GaGa, and many more who at least aren't familiar with her. I mean, the only reason I've seen her so much is because I live in the U.S. And the only reason I've heard more than a few seconds of her music is because I looked her up. If you don't listen to the radio or watch celebrity/music stations, you'd only ever see her on magazines as you do your grocery shopping. (Well, it may be a little harder than that for many in the U.S., but that's more than true for Asian countries, I'm sure.)

[Cherry Dynamite]

Originally Posted by Yumsushi

So that's 2 songs out of how many that don't make any sense? Maybe you should visit her solo work.

I kinda know most of her work actually. I think her english are decent pretty much cutesy on February6 and well I can't explain her english on Heavenly6 but at least it's better than a lot of J-pop artist.

Originally Posted by FuNsTyLe

Those of you who say you didn't even think about Gaga when you saw the SLT preview must have some kind of eye disease. Or be blind...
Didn't have time to read through 5 pages here, but I guess most of you highly disagree because you love her so much

I personally didn't think of Gaga when I saw the preview... why? because I just don't care if it looks like Gaga or any artist work for that matter. It's Ayu's song why should I think of other artist when I'm watching her vids?

Anyways here's a skit I made

Gaga Fan : Ayu's Duty cover was a copy of Gaga's Telephone costume and she copied Gaga's video for her SLT PV because Gaga designed all those clothes that's why she's the only one who could wear it and Gaga made the White background she's the only one who should use it.

Ayu Fan : No Ayu didn't... And stupid Duty was released way before Gaga.

Gaga Fan : Well Ayu still copied Gaga, Nothing can change that because she invented weird.

Sane Person : You're both idiots... Originality died like 50 years ago..
No one's original right now. They're either a complete rip-off or they put their own twist on the existing style.


Anyways I love both of them but I listen to both of them for different reasons

[truehappiness]

I actually didn't really care about GaGa until a friend got obsessed with her and started linking me to a ton of GaGa things. Other than that, I'd probably never really even care about her, haha.

[love in music]

Originally Posted by FuNsTyLe

blah blah blah you're all blind stans etc because you don't agree with me GaGa is god and invented weird hand movements and fashion etc

Didn't have time to read through 5 pages here, but I guess most of you highly disagree because you love her so much

I'm pretty sure people disagree because they disagree. It has nothing to do with "loving her so much", at least not for me. But I guess it makes you feel better to say that the people who don't agree with you are stans or blind or whatever.

[C+R+E+AYUMI]

Originally Posted by GRACE

McQueen died after Sexy little things was recorded.

imo, haters gonna hate. The thing that'll annoy them the most is if you don't respond to them

my god, in the world there aren`t thousend of top stylist, if she used the same stylist this won`t mean she copied GaGa or everyone else.
And even if she copied, do we really care?
Honestly I`m interestend in listening a good song and watching a well designed PV. that`s ALL.

[Aditmi Krisnasaki ~II~]

Originally Posted by FuNsTyLe

Those of you who say you didn't even think about Gaga when you saw the SLT preview must have some kind of eye disease. Or be blind...

I'm not gonna argue, it's just my opinion, and alot of other people on youtube and a few here. Most of you are hardcore Ayu fans and cannot really see it from "outside the box". Too caught up in Ayu and getting on the aggressive/defensive side whenever someone says something that doesn't suit your own opinions.

Ayu isn't the number one fashion and trend setter in the world. Not saying Gaga is either, but she has started a new thing, and Ayu is clearly taking alot of inspiration from her.

Didn't have time to read through 5 pages here, but I guess most of you highly disagree because you love her so much

=='

if you hate ayu and if you hate us who try to defend ayu, then why you joined this forum? LOL

trying some cruel intentions, haters? LOL

[Aditmi Krisnasaki ~II~]

Originally Posted by truehappiness

Most awkward part of the article imo is when the columnist mentions that she's been through multiple cosmetic surgeries... -shakes head-

and Gaga has done nose job too before! duh!

Originally Posted by FuNsTyLe

Those of you who say you didn't even think about Gaga when you saw the SLT preview must have some kind of eye disease. Or be blind...

I'm not gonna argue, it's just my opinion, and alot of other people on youtube and a few here. Most of you are hardcore Ayu fans and cannot really see it from "outside the box". Too caught up in Ayu and getting on the aggressive/defensive side whenever someone says something that doesn't suit your own opinions.

Ayu isn't the number one fashion and trend setter in the world. Not saying Gaga is either, but she has started a new thing, and Ayu is clearly taking alot of inspiration from her.

Didn't have time to read through 5 pages here, but I guess most of you highly disagree because you love her so much

The only person I'm a huuuge fan of isn't even a singer...

Seriously, don't just accuse people of being stans when they have a different opinion than you. If you've read any of my posts, you'd know I haven't been really liking Ayu's style lately. That being said, it's not my love for Ayu that makes me not see "GaGa" in the video. Maybe it's because... I TRY MY BEST TO AVOID ANYTHING "GAGA".

And nope, I was able to read your post, so I don't think I'm blind.

And oh, you actually take people on YouTube's opinions into consideration? No, seriously. I'm not trying to be mean, but people on YT shouldn't be allowed to type.

[microphone]

Originally Posted by FuNsTyLe

Those of you who say you didn't even think about Gaga when you saw the SLT preview must have some kind of eye disease. Or be blind...

I'm not gonna argue, it's just my opinion, and alot of other people on youtube and a few here. Most of you are hardcore Ayu fans and cannot really see it from "outside the box". Too caught up in Ayu and getting on the aggressive/defensive side whenever someone says something that doesn't suit your own opinions.

Ayu isn't the number one fashion and trend setter in the world. Not saying Gaga is either, but she has started a new thing, and Ayu is clearly taking alot of inspiration from her.

Didn't have time to read through 5 pages here, but I guess most of you highly disagree because you love her so much

you don't know how to think beyond yourself. Even if you can't understand it, you should not say something so ignorant like that. I say you have a brain problem because of your opinion. Is that fair for me to say?

You don't know Ayumi's career, it seems. She's been doing this strange fashion for so many years. Suddenly, it is the work of Lady Gaga? No one said she is a global trendsetter, but why do you say Lady Gaga is her inspiration if Ayumi is doing what she has always done?

Do not give blame to fans because you have a different thought. It is so child-like. I challenge you to say Ayumi has inspiration from Madonna. I promise you will not get the same reaction. Why don't you think "outside the box" ?

[Zeke.]

Originally Posted by Aditmi Krisnasaki ~II~

=='

if you hate ayu and if you hate us who try to defend ayu, then why you joined this forum? LOL

trying some cruel intentions, haters? LOL

See, I don't think most people are saying "she copied" - but it's similar. Reminiscent of GaGa recently.

[mmaibff]

I'm too lazy to quote and go through everything atm but I think the reason everyone thinks she copying Lady Gaga is because the clothing are very similar in style, for being very out their and bizarre. But like mention in the first post this is due to the fact that they are by the SAME DESIGNER so of course there is going to be similarity. Personally I feel that this whole album is has a European theme or just a London theme and this isn't a new development I think its been leading up to this for a while. With the whole RIMMEL ads I think it may have built up from there with the whole "European feel" and I think she decided to focus on that aspect for this album, which is why the PV's were film in London and such. But honestly all we can really do is speculate unless we get an official message from Ayu we can't really know

[Tony G]

its pretty simple:

ayu did bizarre clothes before gaga

so gaga can gtfo

[Tony G]

http://gwareth.org/gallery/d/71617-1/screenshot0951.png

GAGA COPY

[Cherry Dynamite]

^ LOL

On the other hand
It's funny that when people lost interest on Ayu and started hating her, They still lurk around the forums and do nothing but troll.

[Choyan]

vateva~~~

see if either artists care lol~

[alternarist]

almost every outfit of Lady GaGa is outrageous. ayu only does it once in a while. i am out of the discussion about who copy who because its really LAME to talk about this. -___-

[Moonstar]

Ayu was way before gaga!That is all I`m saying!!
And also you have to look on the videos...I mean sorry but I don`t see a naked ayu jumping around the videos!^^
So no!!!She isn`t like gaga!!

[tetsuo69]

If she copy anyone on this video, it was Batman The Joker XD LOED

[jbrat2219]

Originally Posted by FuNsTyLe

Those of you who say you didn't even think about Gaga when you saw the SLT preview must have some kind of eye disease. Or be blind...

I'm not gonna argue, it's just my opinion, and alot of other people on youtube and a few here. Most of you are hardcore Ayu fans and cannot really see it from "outside the box". Too caught up in Ayu and getting on the aggressive/defensive side whenever someone says something that doesn't suit your own opinions.

Ayu isn't the number one fashion and trend setter in the world. Not saying Gaga is either, but she has started a new thing, and Ayu is clearly taking alot of inspiration from her.

Didn't have time to read through 5 pages here, but I guess most of you highly disagree because you love her so much

Yeah okay, I have an eye disease because I didn't think of Gaga when I saw SLT. Some people don't have Gaga on the brain 24/7 and some people have a different point of view outside of fan bias. It may be undeniable that the outfits are Gaga-ish but that doesn't mean one has to necessarily think of her. ESPECIALLY, when this particular artist, Ayumi Hamasaki, is known for doing this for a while. It's almost like saying Madonna or Grace Jones drew inspiration from Gaga if they decide to dress weird tomorrow. Yes, Ayu may be taking inspiration, but to call people blind or claim they have some disease because they don't connect it all to Gaga is rude.