"Song 4 u" - Tales of Xillia 2 theme song revealed at TGS2012! - Page 7

njanjayrp · #**121** 23rd September 2012, 04:05 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by isthisLOL?

Do we KNOW for sure a longer version exists? This may be it. The (XILLIA2 ver.) seems to hint at a different version existing, but who knows if it will have additional verses? I'd be happy with a one verse-one chorus song. It's an interesting stylistic decision and a longer song would mainly have more repetition. Who says every song needs to be verse-chorus-verse-chorus-instrumental part/bridge-chorus?

It doesn't, still Mirror was considered an interlude and so was Cather In The Light, this isn't that longer than those actually.

Jawdarna · #**122** 23rd September 2012, 04:06 PM

If I recall correctly, progress was only released two/three months before FIVE was released?

Considering that it's nearly the end of September, and that Ayu has material left over from Party Queen...
I think that a mini-album isn't out of the question.
Especially considering that we've only received a preview for Song 4 u.
It seems extremely suspicious.
Also, considering ToX's release date in November...
Why wouldn't she release something around that time, when she receives extra promotion?
I mean, FIVE was released in conjunction with ToX (FIVE was released a week before hand?)

So, either mini-album or physical single?
Something is going to be released soon.

AyuWorld · #**123** 23rd September 2012, 04:06 PM

ok really Timmy is working on a new song! he said it twitter so is that mean we will get a physical single soon??

Timmy replied to someone just now :

Quote:

I was trying to be poetic (and scatological) when describing my rate of progress on a song I'm working on at the moment lol xxx

so either a mini or a single and meanwhile Timmy's fans will be happy xD

LeeLeeNeko · #**124** 23rd September 2012, 04:07 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by isthisLOL?

Do we KNOW for sure a longer version exists? This may be it. The (XILLIA2 ver.) seems to hint at a different version existing, but who knows if it will have additional verses?

Why would they even bother doing only a short song for a trailer when they have 80% of the whole structure etc ?

It's obvious we'll get a full version, as you said the XILLIA2 ver. is obviously there because it's only the short mix used for the trailer.

Cornie · #**125** 23rd September 2012, 04:07 PM

I think, if the song don't have a longer version, than that is really unusual, Ayu always have long songs (4-5 min)

njanjayrp · #**126** 23rd September 2012, 04:10 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by AyuWorld

ok really Timmy is working on a new song! he said it twitter so is that mean we will get a physical single soon??

Timmy replied to someone just now :

so either a mini or a single and meanwhile Timmy's fans will be happy xD

Timmy doesn't have to only compose stuff for Ayu...

AyuWorld · #**127** 23rd September 2012, 04:13 PM

^ yes i know but considering hes now working with Ayu had only been tweeting about his new compositions for Ayu before this so i expect that this maybe for Ayu's new stuff too

Yagami Raito · #**128** 23rd September 2012, 04:14 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by njanjayrp

Timmy doesn't have to only compose stuff for Ayu...

Somehow he has to

Jawdarna · #**129** 23rd September 2012, 04:20 PM

Hasn't Ayu said that she does everything at the last minute?

He could well be composing for her.

Delicious n Bold · #**130** 23rd September 2012, 04:24 PM

Well, I hope there is a full version. The song has promise and I need a promising ayu song. This year has been just sad... Not terribly sad. Like someone said, it's time to move on from FIVE/PQ and begin anew.

freedreamer · #**131** 23rd September 2012, 04:24 PM

The 2 U Yeah and 4 U Yeah parts are so

Cornie · #**132** 23rd September 2012, 04:31 PM

Ok, I must calm down, next day i will have a job interview.
I will be back later, hopefully they announce something in the next two week..

AyuWorld · #**133** 23rd September 2012, 04:36 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by freedreamer

The 2 U Yeah and 4 U Yeah parts are so

Totally the best part! stuck in my head now

well i didnt realized that she said "2 U and 4 U" until i saw the lyrics LOL

TeamAyu2004 · #**134** 23rd September 2012, 04:59 PM

well its a little disappointing that its only 2 + minutes, but it does say Xillia version... so Im hoping we get a full version...
After all progress had the 'anime' version as well.

They must be doing a mini... I would prefer a single, but I can deal with the mini.

I didn't realize that this forum was expecting a full version of the song... lol
thats asking for WAY too much when the game doesnt even get released till the beginning of November.

ayumi a troll... lol, whatever.

LeeLeeNeko · #**135** 23rd September 2012, 06:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by TeamAyu2004

I didn't realize that this forum was expecting a full version of the song... lol
thats asking for WAY too much when the game doesnt even get released till the beginning of November.

Because asking the fans to pay 200yen for a preview isn't WAY too much ??

At least if they just released it as ringtones I wouldn't mind, but making a digital single just for 2 minutes...

ExodusUK · #**136** 23rd September 2012, 06:47 PM

They put the short version of You & Me on youtube for free and that was popular so I guess they felt they missed a trick and figured they can make fans pay for previews.

TeamAyu2004 · #**137** 23rd September 2012, 06:47 PM

^^ but its not a preview of the song.
Its the full opening to the game...

tokyoxjapanxfan · #**138** 23rd September 2012, 06:49 PM

I think it's stranger that they released it to begin with if it's only 2 minutes. I mean, they could have just put it on YouTube like they did with You & Me, but they wanted to get as much money as possible out of the 2 minutes preview.

First, excited fans buy it through ringtones, then they buy it on iTunes or other net based sites.

They got people to potentially pay twice for a 2 minute clip, which I think is sad.

I enjoy the song, but yeah, I suppose I was expecting a full song. Maybe it was written somewhere that it wasn't in full, but when you say the theme song is going to be released digitally, that doesn't really scream "snippet" to me, lol.

TeamAyu2004 · #**139** 23rd September 2012, 06:54 PM

^ but its not the snippet... its the full theme song to the game. ( and to my understanding itunes isn't really big in japan? it's the other website thing...)

I think people are forgetting about progress.

It wasn't available for download or to buy, but we first got it as the opening theme.
To expect the actual song for download when it wasn't even announced till like 3 days before hand is a little bit of an over expectation.

tokyoxjapanxfan · #**140** 23rd September 2012, 07:06 PM

Maybe I'm in the minority, but I consider a theme song to be the full song. Just because they only use a small portion of it doesn't mean that's the decided theme song, in my mind.

If that's the way you see things then that's fine, you won't see anything wrong then.

But my opinion on the way it was distributed isn't going to change.

Perhaps if they officially titled it "xillia2 version" on the website, my mindset would have been at a different place, but that's not how I first saw it.