CAROLS?
 

I really don't like this song.
The PV was boring, although the merry-go-round was rather enchanting,
it makes me kinda pensive/sentimental.

Other than that, I didnt think this was too good of an ayu song.
To me, it's about as good as an "Over" or "Close to you." :o

It was okay - I just didn't think it was worthy of all the attention we gave it.


(although the hammond whisper mix was totally new and original, it was kind of a bore too.)

I was wondering if anyone agreed. :lech :lech :lech

Well I think it's better than Moments, GAME, and INSPIRE combined...

People say they hate her vocals in this song, which I really don't get. It sounds almost exactly like her voice in 2001 to me... :rolleyes

i love the song, its a nice change from the devistating aftermath of INSPIRE. i do think it was overrated though. i think Moments is a lot better and i can listen to moments nonstop on end but carols gets old. the song itself was not boring, only the hammond mix and the pv. in. my. opinion.

hey hey, nicely put.

But Phantoma... Really, 2001? Isn't that I am...? :rolleyes

Yep...

I think Moments is a lot more overrated, all the 'la la's' just suck...

I thought the remix was a bore, but the song itself is definately better than Over or Close to you.

I did love CAROLS at first, but by the time the original release came out I was fairly bored of it, which is the exact thing that happened to me with Voyage.

Moments was better than INSPIRE, GAME and CAROLS combined for me. :P

Hey, I love Close to You. Yeah, I can see what you mean though, Carols is like "Oh that's pretty." and that's about it.

GOSH i love how perceptive you are
[scratches you behind the ears] :D :innocent :lech

I think CAROLS is an excellent song, just like Over and Close to you are excellent as well. :P At the first times I listened to CAROLS I thought it was really good, a week after I was finding the song terribly annoying specially because of the bridge (go figure why). A week later though I was loving the song back again. I sang to it several times while I was driving (not as much as I did with Moments though, almost anytime I would get in the car I would sing that song).

I personally like Over and Close to you but that's my opinion.I thought CAROLS was good but I have to agree with you ~K+ that Moments was better than INSPIRE,GAME, and CAROLS combined.Moments is my favorite Ayu song and in my opninon her best so far.

Moments is definitely the best song going into My Story that I've heard of so far. But I definitely like Carols too, it gets kind of old after a while but it's kind of sweet I think. Plus I love the PV! It's really simple but for some reason I think it's really nice. And I liked Over too! :yes

^__^ i love CAROLS! it's a really pretty song.. however it's not as good as Moments

I thought Ayumi's vocal in CAROLS was kinda digitalized. ;; But the song itself otherwise was very beautiful. I must the PV disapointed me though. I hoped for better.. Especially my imagination brought me to such a high point.

On scale of 100, it's a 82. Not failing bad, but nothing to go caroling around about either

I loved 'CAROLS'! Yeah like everyone said wasn't as good as 'Moments' thought but it was a really solid song. Personally I like 'INSPIRE' and 'GAME' more, I'm a HUGE fan of that single besides the fact it's a DOUBLE A-SIDE! ARGH WHAT A WASTE OF MONEY, just for a pretty cover and loud instrumentals. Ugh could have gone to my copy of 'MY STORY'. Anyways I really liked 'CAROLS' was extremely beautiful, I didn't really like it at first but after a LONG... break from it, it suddenly became extremely beautiful and the chorus is very memorable and I also LOVE the bridge.

Lastly... 'Over' IS AMAZING. I LOVE THAT SONG, it's a masterpiece. It has the emotional element that some of her recent songs lack like 'INSPIRE' even though I heart that song to DEATH.

CAROLS is actually one of my favorite Ayu PVs, and I'm buying the CD+DVD for only that PV. It tied with Moments for me. I love the part towards the end of the song, the part in the PV where it zooms in on her on the merry-go-round...:)

CAROLS & Moments definetely beat INSPIRE & GAME...:D

I like CAROLS a lot, I think it's really pretty. But I must admit that the PV is pretty disappointing... even when I wasn't expecting much anyway. But I still like it, I definitely don't HATE the PV... it's just, ehhh. But I really like the song, it's one of her better recent ballads.

I like CAROLS, it's a nice song. I think it's a simple and clean track, with the same idea in the PV. The PV was honest, just focusing on Ayu and the song, I love the PV. But I agree that Moments was Ayu's best song this year, it contains some of her best lyrics.

well the verse on carols is great... but i think the chorus makes some point loss on it :D