Taylor Swift vs. Carrie Underwood
 

Who is better considering the following from most important:

1 - music/songs
2 - lyrics
4 - looks
5 - character
6 - performances

I'll post my vote later, hehehehe.

I like them both, but I like Carrie better. :)

I really do love Taylor Swift but I love Carrie much more!

musically - I like Carrie.
lyrically - I like both.
looks wise - they're both pretty girls but Carrie is prettier.
Characters - I haven't watched a lot of interviews and such too see how they are.
Performances - Carrie. Sometimes Taylor sounds like she's struggling =\

music/songs -------------
lyrics------------------------
looks----------------------------- CARRIE
character--------------------
performances-------------

ALL CARRIE!

i prever carrie for great voice

i prefer Taylor Swift, sorry guys...

why not Carrie? here's what doesn't impress me about her:
-she's cheap in not composing/writing her own songs/lyrics
-she's pretty, but she has this sour look to her that i don't fancy
-her voice is amazing, but sometimes, it sounds way toooo cowgirlish, a bit tight, and whiny at times no matter what the song.
-her character... in her interviews and such, lately, it seems she's been letting her fame get to her head.
**THE UPS for Carrie? her performances, she is flawless in comparison to Taylor! Taylor needs to rehearse more!!!

why i love Taylor:
she writes/composes most of her songs... and they're so well written and unlike any other lyrics/song. plus, her voice is so soothing and fresh. i can breathe listening to her. she's like the Shania Twain (voice-wise) of this generation, only a bit better... much more beautiful.
Taylor has this refreshing look with gorgeous facial features that don't look awkward in any angle.
she is so humble, so down to earth, and REAL. her character is so attractive.
**THE DOWNSIDE: this lady needs to do better in her live performances. really really.

i really don't like them both, but i'll say taylor

Taylor Swift is ftw

Crap, I voted Taylor but I meant to vote "neither" lol. Hate country.

I LOVE Carrie Underwood and Taylor Swift is good too, but a lot of Swift's songs are very similar to one another.. @_@