Quote:
Originally Posted by noidea
showing a lot of emotion doesnt necessarily mean its live(gotta watch the performance again to see if it has effect on her voice though), it could even be a reason for singing it playback because crying while singing = bad voice
but I never thought that performance was playback and I think nobody did, even people going to the tour said its live(SunshineSlayer I think)
|
Yeah, Miss Understood was for sure live. Never had any suspicions about that one.
Quote:
Originally Posted by PinkShinigami
^ Yeah, but just because it's the same, I don't see why it should be playback?
|
Because - as those who have seen several live shows know - no song ever sounds exactly the same twice if it really is live. They can sound similar of course, but for them to be exactly the same is a very rare occurrence - I find this to be especially true for rock songs. For example, just compare the tv performances of Talkin' 2 Myself - none of them sound the same; all have at the very least, slight differences in them.