So...playback pops out in every second thread it seems, so I decided to make one thread for discussions about playback, I know theres an old thread(around 2006 or something?) ariound, but I can't use the search and the user who created that thread maybe isn't around anymore.
So, I think a list with all ever performed songs will be a good idea, so every single song can be checked and if someone knows/can prove that a song is playback or live, he/she can write in this topic or PM me and ill add a note in this post after the song^^
OK, starting with the list:
Songs colored blue means the song is (probably)live, songs colored red means its (probably)playback, songs colored black means theres no proof for it being live or playback, theres a little comment for every song(grey).
We can NEVER say for sure something is playback or live unless ayu makes a mistake, so please consider that a marked song doesn't necessarily means it is playback or live, but that it's MOST LIKELY playback/live(depending on the colour), that's the reason theres a little comment for every song, to discribe why I/we think it's playback or live.
It is possible that information are wrong.
Tours
Quote:
Quote:
ARENA TOUR 2009 A
- no information about playback yet -
01. Pieces of SEVEN
02. Rule
03. UNITE!
04. Disco-munication
05. EnergizE
06. AUDIENCE
07. Load of the SHUGYO
08. LOVE 'n' HATE
09. identity
10. In The Corner
11. HOPE or PAIN
12. GREEN
13. Days
14. evolution
15. SIGNAL
16. rollin'
17. Sparkle
18. Bridge to the Sky
19. NEXT LEVEL
20. Curtain Call
21. For My Dear...
22. everywhere nowhere
23. Boys & Girls
24. MY ALL
|
Quote:
ASIA TOUR 2008 ~10th Anniversary~
00. reBIRTH
01. The Judgement Day
02. talkin' 2 myself
TV version and DVD version are the same, News excerpts and Fancams need to be checked.
03a. is this LOVE?
not checked yet
03b. A Song for XX
not checked yet
04. Depend On You
You can hear Ayu laugh at one point(she's showing thumbs up to Shuya)
05. Fly High
not checked yet
06. (don't) Leave me Alone
The part after she gets off the wheel is definitly live, because you can hear her voice being shaky when she hits the air, but the part where she's hanging on the wheel may still be playback from the first part of the tour(she was spinning while singing for a few concerts and people said it's playback because of that), you also hear almost no microphone noises in the beginning, too.
07. decision
microphone noises
08. my name's WOMEN
microphone noises and struggling while dancing(she stopps notes to early because she needs to move for example)
09. Marionette -prelude-
10. Marionette
TV version and DVD version are the same, fancams seem to be the same, but more comparing should be done to be 100% sure
11. HANABI
not checked yet
12. End Roll
not checked yet
13. tasking
14. SURREAL~evolution~SURREAL
Ayu forgot her lines in evolution(TV version)
15. Mirrorcle World
TV version and DVD version are different
16. Dearest
not checked yet
17. Voyage
not checked yet
18. Humming 7/4
not checked yet
19. Boys & Girls
not checked yet
20. MY ALL
not checked yet
|
Quote:
ASIA TOUR 2007 : TOUR OF SECRET A
01. LABYRINTH
02. evolution
It's the same CDL0607 and CDL0708 were, so it's probably playback.(fancams need to be checked to be sure)
The beginning part where she's hanging in the air is live most likely though.(There's vibrato in a fancam but not in the DVD)
03. UNITE!
not checked yet
04. taskinst
05. 1 LOVE
There's speculations about it being playback
06. until that Day...
Same as 1LOVE
07. M
not checked yet
08. appears
not checked yet
09. part of Me
not checked yet
10. Secret
not checked yet
11. kiss o' kill
not checked yet
12. Not yet
13. SURREAL
not checked yet
14. AUDIENCE
not checked yet
15. Boys & Girls
not checked yet
16. SEASONS
not checked yet
17. glitter
not checked yet
18. independent
not checked yet
19. Humming 7/4
not checked yet
20. Who...
not checked yet
The reason most songs say "not checked yet" is, that I don't want to watch AT07 often before I buy a copy of it(I intend to buy a copy in the following months), simply to not take all the excitement for it, so I myself can't say much about playback and live in AT07, theres also the problem of very heavy editing in the DVD, making it hard to see what is playback, because almost all the concert SEEMS playback on the DVD.
|
Quote:
ARENA TOUR 2006 (miss)understood A
01. Are You Wake Up?
02. Born To Be...
not checked yet
03. AUDIENCE
not checked yet
04. evolution
not checked yet
05. STEP you
highly doubted because of no mic noises and breathing, the mouth movements seem false as well
06. Ladies Night
microphone noises in the beginning, ending doesnt have them, maybe starts off live and changes to playback later?
07. alterna
highly doubted because of the movements which seem to have no effect on ayu's voice, also no mic noises
08. is this LOVE?
not checked yet
09. (miss)understood
not checked yet
10. tasking
11. Pride
not checked yet
12. rainy day
not checked yet
13. Startin'
not checked yet
14. UNITE!
not checked yet
15. Bold & Delicious
not checked yet
16. HEAVEN
not checked yet
17. teens
not checked yet
18. BLUE BIRD
not checked yet
19. Humming 7/4
not checked yet
20. Boys & Girls
not checked yet
21. Beautiful Day
not checked yet
|
more will be added in the next days, im sorry i dont have time to add other concerts now, tomorrow ill have much time^^
|
Countdowns
a-nations
others
TV appereances
Quote:
|
May come never...(too many performances!)
|
Start discussing xD(if you find something to discuss about) as i wrote, i cant make all the post now because its quite much work^^
14th April 2009, 07:14 PM
COMPLETE playback thread
Threaded Mode