Ayu's vocal this year...

[prussian blue]

Originally Posted by SolarAngel

I thought it was lipsynched too until i listened to the live TV version. That was definitely not lipsynched. There were too many flat notes and cut off lines. Sometimes the music and audience get too loud for the sound engineers to incorporate the live singing into the DVD so they use the backup track. Or maybe ayu's vocals were too shaky so they decided to do away with the original.

LOL that was the most horrible moment i've heard from ayu. fortunately it was just once... or else, i wont be here anymore.

[SunshineSlayer]

Originally Posted by Andrenekoi

Don't know how to explain this in english, but in Marionette she wasn't using her voice right... she was holding it a lot and wasn't projecting it to outside her... It made her voice a little unclear, talking about the news reports... In the TV Version she was sounding ok, but the sound was edited (as aways). Can't say it was lip synching cause of the tv version lack of sound-video synch also, cause her voice and the scenes are not edited together... It could be just bad edition...

Every single news clip, bootleg etc + now this tv version sounds exactly the same. There isn't a single difference in any of them. There is no way that it is live and to say that it can't be lipsynched because it doesn't sound perfect enough doesn't make sense - no one who is smart these days records perfect versions of songs to lip synch to.

Originally Posted by emiko

Marionette had terrible vocals? What?

Man, I'm sorry this thread is just...starting to be full of...i don't know..."fluff".

Marionette had great vocals. And it was lipsynched. I don't blame her at all for doing it either. I find her movements and stuff entertaining, and I'm pretty sure the reason why she did lipsynch it was because she can't sing bent over like that.

Furthermore, you can tell she isn't singing because her chest isn't moving at all. She moves it when she breathes, only.

Thank you. Finally someone relying on logic here.

[darc_aqua]

her vocals have been getting more shaky and stressed
at least the songs are pretty good. I really want the vocals from 2003-2004 back those were really good to listen to

[Andrenekoi]

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer

Every single news clip, bootleg etc + now this tv version sounds exactly the same. There isn't a single difference in any of them. There is no way that it is live and to say that it can't be lipsynched because it doesn't sound perfect enough doesn't make sense - no one who is smart these days records perfect versions of songs to lip synch to.

didn't sound the same to me... and one thing it to record flawed vocals to sound live... another one is to record atrocious ones... MNW in this tour sounds terrible, if she is going to use this kind of pre recorded vocals, she is not that smart...

I'm taking taking lessons... a good singer can tell you if someone ate something before singing... I'm not in this level yet, but I can note some voice aspects I couldn't before starting the lessons... Marionette live and Marionette in TV version doesn't sound the same... If she was using good pre recorded vocals, she would not edit her voice in the broadcasting version...

Ok, I'm not going to say anything more about this issue... ~~
Doesn't matter if she is singing live or not, she still makes more money than us that keep discussing it....

[SunshineSlayer]

Originally Posted by Andrenekoi

didn't sound the same to me... and one thing it to record flawed vocals to sound live... another one is to record atrocious ones... MNW in this tour sounds terrible, if she is going to use this kind of pre recorded vocals, she is not that smart...

I'm taking taking lessons... a good singer can tell you if someone ate something before singing... I'm not in this level yet, but I can note some voice aspects I couldn't before starting the lessons... Marionette live and Marionette in TV version doesn't sound the same... If she was using good pre recorded vocals, she would not edit her voice in the broadcasting version...

The only difference in the broadcast version is that everything sounds clearer than it does in bootleg or newscast versions. The actual vocals themselves are the same. If you really can't hear that, then I think you are only hearing what you want to hear...

Originally Posted by Andrenekoi

Doesn't matter if she is singing live or not, she still makes more money than us that keep discussing it....

haha, that's true.

[~*Mabushii*~]

I think she did amazing singing Days live..
it was really good compared to earlier when she first announced going deaf in her ear

[mangoo_x3]

when it comes the her vocals in the studio, I am satisifed. Like in GREEN she actually held a high note. For her live performances I have to agreee on someone saying how she can't hear herself when she sings soft anymore. Maybe if wore a hearing aid.. maybe that would help because I noticed she doesn't wear one but when she was at her ani tour she was.. i think.

[Heldin]

But what about her A Capella things? Who and Seasons? I liked them very much! I think, she sang them pretty clear.

[ComatoseBunnySnatcher]

Days @ MS was AWESOME!

Way better than the MW lives.