Britney Spears vs. Ayumi Hamasaki .....what do you prefer?

[ayumixfan]

Originally Posted by njanjayrp

1) where did u see I was attacking people?
2) Comparing Britney to Ayu is idiotic imo. You would usually COMPARE things that are similar in a way. (you can't really compare an integer to a real number for example xD)
Are you aware that people get co-writing/producing credits for just sitting in the studio?

^ well I guess its an opinion but I mean I feel its unecessary to say stuff like that because it offends the creator of the thread, I see what u mean by they're different, but hey a forum is just for fun right, we can discuss these things as long as its not offensive. Like I mean its just an opinion. The only reason why I'm always posting in this therad is that I feel people ignore the fact that britney is an artist.

I assume their ideas have to be inputed into it also, because if what ur stating is true then why doesn't britney do it for EVERY SONG. And only a few of them. Like I assume there has to be input/help in creating a song if ur going to label it CO-written and co-produced. I'm jsut a person who gives credit to people if they've been stated for the credit :S because if you look at it from that point of view, we can say that ayu's rainbow album had almost none of her input in it because she co-composed most of the songs. I say if the credit is there for someone then they probably deserve it. And plus Britney Did appear on BoA's album too. I assume she HAD to have musical input/ideas there. Why would she randomly just show up to sit and take credit on BoA's song.

Sorry I'm not trying to troll you or anything, its just I guess we have opposing opinions no matter what. Oh well thats what discussions are for as long as we don't start fighting lol.

@SunshineSlayer: thats true too I guess, but then doesn't that mean her voice deteriorated? Just like Ayu? lol Ayu doesn't sound nearly as good as she did before too, but that doesn't mean they both suck now lol. AS you age unfortunately your voice gets worse I guess you could say britney's voice weakened faster than ayu's voice.