Which concert(s) was(were) sang completely?

[alternarist]

Originally Posted by noidea

@alternarist
You forgot about theme of a-nation '03 in CDL0506, she made a lipping mistake there as well.
And you can't sing twice in the exact same way, how naive are you? Its impossible. Even the best vocalists of the world can't do so. Especially not while dancing, while your ill or when your voice changed drastically over the years.
If proven by a computer thats several times more exact than what humans actually can HEAR, and by hearing you can already say that its the same without doubt, because thats still exact enough.
And how can you assure me that AT07 was all live? Thats WAY more speculation than saying 2 or 3 songs were playback.

1) ok i forgot about theme of a-nation '03.

2) Calling me naive? Try telling this to everyone in the forum and see who believes u. They rather read a magazine than ur "theory" on ayu lip-synching. U cant prove anything with whatever u said.

Originally Posted by noidea

of course, this is nothing to prove anything with it, but it makes sense...

i agree with u that it makes sense. but THIS IS NOTHING TO PROVE ANYTHING!! oh cumon.

3) I have BEEN TO that concert. I have listened to ayu's singing. Beat that.

[noidea]

Originally Posted by alternarist

1) ok i forgot about theme of a-nation '03.

2) Calling me naive? Try telling this to everyone in the forum and see who believes u. They rather read a magazine than ur "theory" on ayu lip-synching. U cant prove anything with whatever u said.



i agree with u that it makes sense. but THIS IS NOTHING TO PROVE ANYTHING!! oh cumon.

3) I have BEEN TO that concert. I have listened to ayu's singing. Beat that.

That doesnt change the fact that your "she sang it completely live" is speculated in just the same way. Your "I was there" is nothing to prove it as well.
U cant prove anything with whatever u said. All I ever wrote makes more sense than your "I was there!!!!!!!" argument. And seriously, I don't believe that they completely replaced the audio for several songs in that tour, and that they even had the oppurtunity to do so, because she usually speaks to the audience and shouts out come on!s in songs like evolution and UNITE!.
many, many people, especially new fans, here belong to the "Ayu is perfect!"-fraction, of course they won't believe me, measuring truth by how many people think it's right is crap. Or do you say the Nazis were right because many people believed Hitler back then?

[keepsgettinbetter]

all i can add tot his is that, during HAPPY ENDING in AT05, you can clearly tell that they used the recorded vocals after the dramatic ending part where shuyu (?) gets carried off stage. it sounds IDENTICLE to the CD.

Originally Posted by noidea

That doesnt change the fact that your "she sang it completely live" is speculated in just the same way. Your "I was there" is nothing to prove it as well.
U cant prove anything with whatever u said. All I ever wrote makes more sense than your "I was there!!!!!!!" argument. And seriously, I don't believe that they completely replaced the audio for several songs in that tour, and that they even had the oppurtunity to do so, because she usually speaks to the audience and shouts out come on!s in songs like evolution and UNITE!.
many, many people, especially new fans, here belong to the "Ayu is perfect!"-fraction, of course they won't believe me, measuring truth by how many people think it's right is crap. Or do you say the Nazis were right because many people believed Hitler back then?

this is my favourite post out of all your amazing posts in this thread.