What's the difference(s) between Endless sorrow PV: Original & Extended version ?

[ayumaria]

Hi !

I've just DL Endless sorrow PV, but I don't know... was mine is an Original or Extended version...

It starts with a guy singing, and suddenly he got ambushed by several M.I.B ..... bla..bla...bla......... near the end, ayu picked up the white feather and look up....

So, which one is it ? Original or Extended ?

And, what's the difference(s) between them ?

Also, I wanna know... how many official remix PV existed ?
So far, I only knew the following:
01. M [Above & Beyond remix] (my fav !)
02. Dearest [Laugh & Peace MIX]
03. poker face [Spiritual Guidance Mix]

So, are there any other(s) that I don't know ?

Hihihi, thanx in advance !



ayumaria.

[ImpactBreaker]

Dearest [Laugh & Peace MIX] and
poker face [Spiritual Guidance Mix] PV are not official! They were fan made That is actually the original poker face PV replaced with the remix.
As for M above & Beyond it truly is official. The other Remix PV is Kanariya Jonathan Peter's Mix, Fly high HAL's mix 2000 and Dearest Acoustic orchestra Version.

The Endless Sorrow you listened to in the PV is the original single version. However the one in the single doesn't have the guy saying "give me freedom, give me hope", it was just added in the PV. The album version of Endless sorrow is actually a remix (Gone with the wind).

[Unimatrix Prime™]

I had posted all of what Impact said til the original thread ayumaria posted suddenly disappeared.. o_o

Also, the Daybreak PV was the "Hal's Mix 2002" version, which could be considered the original mix as well .

[ImpactBreaker]

Oh Daybreak HAL's Mix 2002 too

[leafyamazaki]

Regarding the PV... The Original one, which was the one showed on TV, didn't include the part with ayu picking up the feather at the end and a flash from the making of the PV at the beginning. It just started with the guy singing, then ended with the feather falling and then changed to a view of a tower. The extended one, which was included in A Clips vol.2, included the things I just mentioned.

so does the Clips Box include the PV with Ayu picking up the feather at the end? or no?

[leafyamazaki]

Hmmm... there're two possibilities - it does or doesn't.
Someone with the CCB might be able to answer it though... I can't cause my copy was just shipped yesterday.

[Unimatrix Prime™]

Originally posted by leafyamazaki
Regarding the PV... The Original one, which was the one showed on TV, didn't include the part with ayu picking up the feather at the end and a flash from the making of the PV at the beginning. It just started with the guy singing, then ended with the feather falling and then changed to a view of a tower. The extended one, which was included in A Clips vol.2, included the things I just mentioned.

Oh yeah.. I mentioned that in my initial reply as well (before it disappeared), but I've always wondered why they made 2 versions of the PV

[ayumaria]

Oh, so.. mine is an Extended version ?
Coz' I see ayu picking the feather in the end ?
If so, how lucky I am to have the Extended PV !

lol Dearest & poker face ----> fan made ?!?!?!
Uwwaaa ?!?! I thought they were official all this time ?!?!
Coz' the timing was so perfect !?!?!
WOW, whoever done this.... VERY BRILLIANT !!

Oh, and about the other PV(s)...
I've got the DVD entitled Hamasaki Ayumi which the cover show ayu's face in red...and consists of all first 12 PV(s) starting from poker face until Fly high...

And, yes, I watch the kanariya PV. It is JP's remix, but edited into shorter one. And, Fly high PV, it is HAL's MIX 2000.
I'm very sure about these, coz' I got the single(s) too.

And, Daybreak.
I've got the PV, but I found it is different from the one I have on I am... album...... So, this one must be HAL's MIX 2002 !

OK, last question !
Was the PV for Dearest AOV the same as the original PV ?
Only replaced with the AOV, but using the original PV ?

Hihihi, that's all !
Thanx you very much !



ayumaria.

[leafyamazaki]

The PV for Dearest ~Acoustic Piano Version~ (not Acoustic Orchestra)
was very much different from the Original Mix PV. The scenes in the APV one was just the part with the wind generators.

The PV for Endless sorrow (the extended version) isn't really rare. As I said it's on A clips vol.2... and most probably Complete Clip Box.

[CREA]

Originally posted by leafyamazaki
Hmmm... there're two possibilities - it does or doesn't.
Someone with the CCB might be able to answer it though... I can't cause my copy was just shipped yesterday.

The extended version of "Endless sorrow" is the one included in the complete clip box. (where she picks up the feather at the end)

[leafyamazaki]

Originally posted by CREA
The extended version of "Endless sorrow" is the one included in the complete clip box. (where she picks up the feather at the end)

oh... Thanks for clarifying that, ^_^

[PickleCookies]

Originally posted by ImpactBreaker
Dearest [Laugh & Peace MIX]

Actually, that's an official one. That's why it was on tv.


Dearest (Laugh & Peace Mix)
Dearest (Acoustic Orchestra Version)
M (Above & Beyond)

are official. eneabba.net has a them all in the video list.

[leafyamazaki]

I think you meant Dearest ~Acoustic Piano Version~...

[boogieordie]

The one that I have isn't official.. it's just the regular one with the remix pasted over it.. obviously fan made.. what's the real one?

The difference is just that the "extended" one on A Clips has Ayu in it at the end. She wasn't in the first music video.

Ashley

[kournikova]

i dont know the difference... so thx for the information!

[ayumaria]

Uhhhh, I've got confused again !
ImpactBreaker said Dearest [Laugh & Peace MIX] is fan made
But, PickleCookies said it was official ??

I only got an .asf version of this PV, and I found mine is just the same as original Dearest PV, only the music is Laugh & Peace MIX.

Anyone got any idea ?



ayumaria.

[leafyamazaki]

The "Laugh & Peace MIX" is official. You'll notice the difference in the last few scenes of the PV.
To get what I mean, watch the two PVs... then watch the last few scenes carefully, it's not "hidden," you'll notice it right away.

[ayumaria]

Yup ! I've got both of them.
But, I'm so busy right now, guess I'll watch them again tonight !
Anyway, thanx for the information, leafyamazaki !



ayumaria.

[starr5245]

kool!! so i have the extended one!!