Thoughts on Alterna PV - Page 11

truehappiness · #**201** 23rd July 2005, 02:59 PM

How awkward. I was watching the beginning and some other parts..and there's that random 'fan' there. Could that possibly be a representation of 'fans' being present in Ayu's life? Then again, I could always be overanalyzing..

Zeo

LX Ayu · #**202** 23rd July 2005, 04:51 PM

its a video, not a symbolic movie

k there could and couldnt be meaning to it

is there meaning to war of the worlds? or does rachel screaming every 2min mean something else? or maybe why the lightning bolts are pink, theres got to be a reason why they are pink and not blue right?

Eigoob · #**203** 23rd July 2005, 05:44 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by truehappiness

How awkward. I was watching the beginning and some other parts..and there's that random 'fan' there. Could that possibly be a representation of 'fans' being present in Ayu's life? Then again, I could always be overanalyzing..

Zeo

I think the fan part is still a bit unclear (maybe it's just a decorative element), because the first few seconds of the PV are missing. The clip we got, begins after the artist/song pop-up disappears, which is usually about 10s or so into the video.

marshey905 · #**204** 23rd July 2005, 06:24 PM

err.. I don't like the song and the video at all.. especially the part where she has the eyeball in her mouth. pretty disturbing..

Surreal · #**205** 23rd July 2005, 06:45 PM

None of us works for Ayu, so NONE OF US can say 'it's just a PV it has no meaning' or 'ayu means it this way in the pv!' and how can anyone be so sure that it's 'just a pv'? are you saying Ayu has no depth? I don't think she takes her career so lightly - refer to how max said that she doesn't half-ass anything

this is a forum open for fan discussions, there's no need to be rude to others' opinions

NyoNyo · #**206** 23rd July 2005, 07:06 PM

not liking the PV. especially the clowns part.

I ALWAYS hate clowns. this time too. The video itself is good, but.........

And the part when she had an eyeball. Ewww~

the song itself is GREAT. REALLY GREAT.

gratz for ayu for making such a great song.

and i'd say "no comment" for the PV....

kyuusei · #**207** 24th July 2005, 03:00 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Surreal

None of us works for Ayu, so NONE OF US can say 'it's just a PV it has no meaning' or 'ayu means it this way in the pv!' and how can anyone be so sure that it's 'just a pv'? are you saying Ayu has no depth? I don't think she takes her career so lightly - refer to how max said that she doesn't half-ass anything

this is a forum open for fan discussions, there's no need to be rude to others' opinions

Exactly. Certainly there's not always a reason for every tiny little detail, but I've noticed - at least for Ayu - that some of the bigger details often mean something, usually to get the point of the song further across. I too think she takes her music seriously enough to at least help put some thought into her PVs other than simply random scenes... which can end up either strangely amusing, kind of stupid... or very boring.

If we feel like analyzing it, great. For anyone who doesn't - carry on. =)

Ibitsu Kokoro · #**208** 24th July 2005, 03:04 AM

The best pv in a long time, although sometimes it looked a bit silly. This pv is similar to ourselves, but different. I like it.

lovia · #**209** 24th July 2005, 05:29 AM

i have to say this pv is really great!! ayu is really honest to herself and to everybody.. such a pv with great meaning.. really which artiste will really admit that they will one day be at the bottom and no longer at the top...
this pv is really great! though it is kind of weird but its real good love it and the music is really different.. not a very common type of jpop music... deliciously unique!
and ayu in white really reminds me of that lady who often wears white and have her dress being blown out from the bottom and she always has her hands to put her skirt down.. i dont know her name.. but ayu really reminds me of her instead of madonna.. and i dont think that ayu is becoming rebellious or something.. it is just that she is becoming more brave to try new things and face changes... and i really hope to see ayu in more and more different styles.. really.. all that cutesy ayu is boring man esp on pvs and leave that to the concert live performances...

kyuusei · #**210** 24th July 2005, 06:27 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by lovia

and ayu in white really reminds me of that lady who often wears white and have her dress being blown out from the bottom and she always has her hands to put her skirt down.. i dont know her name.. but ayu really reminds me of her instead of madonna..

Marilyn Monroe. XD

Syphex · #**211** 24th July 2005, 06:37 AM

This is the most beautiful PV she has ever produced. We need more stuff like this in the world. Brutal Honesty is so evident here, and so unforgiving. The strings using everyone, the clowns representing profit-motivated companies, the copy machine trying to replace the original..wonderful. How can you guys hate it for being wierd? She's being honest and true to herself, like she always wanted to be. She realizes that she's accomplished so much but it will all fall apart at the end. The song itself is great---The guitar is wonderful (Although it didn't have as much influence as is this LOVE? which sucks) My favorite part of the whole song is each time after the chorus, the "hey...hey hey hey hey...." the guitar shines here and makes for a catchy tune. Let me also say that the song fits the PV so well.

One of her finest works. Her pop style may be getting worse from her I Am.. days but her style in rock is getting so much better, and she is maturing as a person which is what I like to see in people. Better then my expectations, and this song is why I continue to listen to Hamasaki.

yukiko · #**212** 24th July 2005, 06:47 AM

i find this video kinda odd........... like the plot seems a bit strange.... is she trying to say that shes been turned into a singing machine???? maybe im thinking too much !! but i think the parts when shes painted white reminds me of some Madonna video for some reason........ i dont think im the only one that has noticed that....

hopeorpain · #**213** 24th July 2005, 06:48 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by yukiko

i find this video kinda odd........... like the plot seems a bit strange.... is she trying to say that shes been turned into a singing machine???? maybe im thinking too much !! but i think the parts when shes painted white reminds me of some Madonna video for some reason........ i dont think im the only one that has noticed that....

lol you're not alone. Doesn't Hikki have an album cover in which she is covered in flour as well? Hehe it's a cool design

kyuusei · #**214** 24th July 2005, 07:14 AM

I don't know if she's trying to say she's been turned into a singing machines, so much as she feels some groups (again, the industry, fans and/or media) sometimes see her that way.

SunshineSlayer · #**215** 24th July 2005, 07:24 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by kyuusei

I don't know if she's trying to say she's been turned into a singing machines, so much as she feels some groups (again, the industry, fans and/or media) sometimes see her that way.

It's also I think referring to the years of 2000-2001 where she really was a "singing machine" putting out singles at an alarming rate (due to the pressure of Avex to keep their profits on the rise) and at one point appeared on over 40 magazine covers in, I believe, only 1 month! Also this was the time when the A Best album was released without her full support. She was quoted at that time as saying that that was when she realized that "Hamasaki Ayumi" was no longer a person, but a product. I think that time period of her life is what the singing machine scene refers to, as well as the article headline "almost human."

hopeorpain · #**216** 24th July 2005, 07:26 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SunshineSlayer

It's also I think referring to the years of 2000-2001 where she really was a "singing machine" putting out singles at an alarming rate (due to the pressure of Avex to keep their profits on the rise) and at one point appeared on over 40 magazine covers in, I believe, only 1 month! Also this was the time when the A Best album was released without her full support. She was quoted at that time as saying that that was when she realized that "Hamasaki Ayumi" was no longer a person, but a product. I think that time period of her life is what the singing machine scene refers to, as well as the article headline "almost human."

Yeah, probably the reason why Ayu is crying on the A Best cover

gogirlanime · #**217** 24th July 2005, 09:10 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by LX Ayu

its a video, not a symbolic movie

k there could and couldnt be meaning to it

is there meaning to war of the worlds? or does rachel screaming every 2min mean something else? or maybe why the lightning bolts are pink, theres got to be a reason why they are pink and not blue right?

Well said, I totally agree <3

NyoNyo · #**218** 24th July 2005, 09:44 AM

well, maybe her lyrics of this song is pointed at paparazzis and mass medias. and the PV is made for telling a story bout herself, from the beginning *when she got a "You're a star!" ticket (is that a ticket?)*, to the point that she was turned into "singing machine", until the time when she'll be forgotten, dumped, even childrens won't care at her. but she'll keep singing and singing. *will that time comes?*

hmm, don't bash me plz, i'm just~ saying what i'm thinking......

#**219** 24th July 2005, 05:24 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by royle

i wonder why at the end of the pv showing a boy is trying to peak the little girl undies ???

'cause all boys are the same

Wow, as if clowns didn't scare me enough

elepop · #**220** 24th July 2005, 05:31 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Syphex

This is the most beautiful PV she has ever produced. We need more stuff like this in the world. Brutal Honesty is so evident here, and so unforgiving. The strings using everyone, the clowns representing profit-motivated companies, the copy machine trying to replace the original..wonderful. How can you guys hate it for being wierd? She's being honest and true to herself, like she always wanted to be. She realizes that she's accomplished so much but it will all fall apart at the end. The song itself is great---The guitar is wonderful (Although it didn't have as much influence as is this LOVE? which sucks) My favorite part of the whole song is each time after the chorus, the "hey...hey hey hey hey...." the guitar shines here and makes for a catchy tune. Let me also say that the song fits the PV so well.

One of her finest works. Her pop style may be getting worse from her I Am.. days but her style in rock is getting so much better, and she is maturing as a person which is what I like to see in people. Better then my expectations, and this song is why I continue to listen to Hamasaki.

Well-said Syphex!

I agree with you.