another similarity between ayu and jolin

[Rurutia]

okay...i'm not bashing jolin.....i like her....well kinda....but i've heard a lot about the uncanny similarities between her and ayu......and i was watching this clip on youtube (ayu cm's) and i saw ayu in a tube thing and it explodes when she presses her hands on the walls.......in jolin's pv wei wu du zun , the same thing happens......thus, i wondered if she once again imitated ayu. you be the judge

ayu
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M7NKR...elated&search=

jolin
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hYjrbahzMag

[Corybobory]

Jolin was on display at a museum... I didnt think it was overly similar...

[Rurutia]

what i was pointing at was the glass exploded.......the motion was the same...just thought it was interesting

[truehappiness]

Eh, that KOSE CM is really old anyway.

Ayu was on display in some museum as well, I think..

[sakamoko]

I can't believe XD Jolin is really an Ayufan xD

[Rurutia]

is jolin an ayu fan? did she ever say that?

[Raleigh]

Guess her director is a copycat of the director of the Visee cm then.

[truehappiness]

This thread's probably gonna bite the big one, hm? :<

Jolin has a lot of issues with having material that is eerily similar to other artists from Japan and so on.. :\

[the angel song]

I'm not gettin' in this one lmao.

[CREA.tive]

Wow this is getting more and more ridiculous. I'm sure there are plenty of other videos in which you see a tube exploding. Did you really have to post that because I could also start a thread about which thing Ayumi copied from Madonna. But again, people would stay: this is a very common thing we see very often. Then that's the same for this.

[FeNgZhEnG]

hmm there were already alot of past similarities btwn jolin and ayumi.. its her company coz they were trying to create jolin into 'taiwan's ayumi'.. even there's a logo of her initial "J" shown on her albums and concerts.. similarities or publicity tactics? we judge ourselves..

[AyuCharm615]

Good one crea..my thoughs exactly!
Did Ayu copy Britney Spears in Startin'?
Yeah...i dont think so..

[Melting_Holidays]

ayu broke the whole glass cage. While jolin broke the sides. Jolin used 2 hands while ayu used 1.

Ayu was being admired while Jolin wasn't.

The only similarity I see is that they where both in a glass cage.

[AyuGAME]

its ok...jolin is ayu fans

[pyro2787]

can someone please provide better evidence of Jolin Tsai copying ayumi hamasaki please, like that chinese mv posted before that looked a lot like the Ourselves video(forgot who did the mv)?

So far, all the videos I've seen with Jolin arent that similar to Ayu, Jolin dances in her mv's and she does a really good job of it too, if i were to say something, she looks like she's copying Koda Kumi, not Ayumi. Also, I would like to add something, so far, I read on other sites that the majority of the people accused Jolin of "looking" like Ayumi or "her hand movements" are like Ayumi, or her fake nails are like Ayumi's... I find this ridiculous because there are tons of other artists who have the same hair style...or wave the same way, if my friend got a haircut like Ayumi, should I bash her for doing so? Or if she spiked her hair, should I bash her for impersonating some rock star? All these "evidence" (that I've seen so far) are too abstract for me to consider it copying...

buuuuuuut if you guys don't agree....talent lives on, once they both get old and wrinkly, they only have their talent left..therefore, I usually look to see if the artist can sing...and I find Jolin a very good singer, therefore, I don't really care if she "copies" Ayumi...unless she over does it like that chinese mv that looked like Ayumi's Ourselves....

[Ayumiko]

I saw this mv of jolins when it first came out and the first thing that came to my mind is the visee cm of ayus. This is very minor compared to the other similarities Ive seen between them. Jolin has a good voice and I think I would enjoy her songs if I didnt have a problem with her.

[rainday]

Oh come ON! The exploding glass effect has been used over and over and over again by people all over the world. Even if somehow you can find a statement from Jolin saying... "YES I SUGGESTED THIS IDEA TO THE DIRECTOR AFTER SEEING AYU'S VIDEO"... Ayu doesn't have a copyright on it.

[LacusClyne]

Originally Posted by FeNgZhEnG

hmm there were already alot of past similarities btwn jolin and ayumi.. its her company coz they were trying to create jolin into 'taiwan's ayumi'.. even there's a logo of her initial "J" shown on her albums and concerts.. similarities or publicity tactics? we judge ourselves..

that is very common. a lot of artist also have their intials into their product.

as for the pvs, well Jolin's 'ling meng cao de wei dao' do look like ayu's 'hanabi~episode II'. but the pv was a long time ago, and recently jolin's tyle DO NOT look like ayu anymore. Jolin had now more controls over her images already.

[kiseki89]

Originally Posted by LacusClyne

that is very common. a lot of artist also have their intials into their product.

as for the pvs, well Jolin's 'ling meng cao de wei dao' do look like ayu's 'hanabi~episode II'. but the pv was a long time ago, and recently jolin's tyle DO NOT look like ayu anymore. Jolin had now more controls over her images already.

This unforturnately I have to agree...
However in my own opinion, she might have more control over her images, they are becoming rather bad - she is trying too hard to be sexy or something. I prefer her older styles.

*spretty pony~pretty pony~pretty pony~pretty pony~pretty pony~pretty pony~*
These threads fail, i'm so sick of seeing them.

>.<