YUI -V.S- Erika Sawajiri as Kaoru Amane from "Taiyou no Uta"

[truehappiness]

o_o ~

I think that in all fairness, musical abilities should be considered as well.. ?

YUI:
Writes, composes, and arranges[?] her own songs.

Erika:
.... just sings? XD

[oro77]

Originally Posted by truehappiness

o_o ~

I think that in all fairness, musical abilities should be considered as well.. ?

YUI:
Writes, composes, and arranges[?] her own songs.

Erika:
.... just sings? XD

I totally agree　
Good-bye days is such a good song, it cannot be beaten by "average" good song like Erika's.

[elepop]

Originally Posted by truehappiness

o_o ~

I think that in all fairness, musical abilities should be considered as well.. ?

YUI:
Writes, composes, and arranges[?] her own songs.

Erika:
.... just sings? XD

It isn't about who composes, writes or arranges. It's about the song itself. Which is better? "Taiyou no Uta" or "Good-bye days"? Not who is better as an artist.

It's not very fair to say what you're saying because Erika is an actress. And YUI a singer. Not suprising that she writes and composes her own songs.

[truehappiness]

Originally Posted by asongforXX

It isn't about who composes, writes or arranges. It's about the song itself. Which is better? "Taiyou no Uta" or "Good-bye days"? Not who is better as an artist.

It's not very fair to say what you're saying because Erika is an actress. And YUI a singer. Not suprising that she writes and composes her own songs.

I guess it's cause I feel like this is reminding my of Hilary Duff and Lindsay Lohan.. o-o LOL~

I do like Good-bye days more though. imo, I don't think Erika Sawajiri will go past being this 'Kaoru Amano' figure.. I think if it were like Kaoru Amano feat. Erika, then there might be hope for some sort of future independent release without the TnU tie-in..

Then again, Erika could go all Aya Ueto on us :p

[destiny_ayu]

*Personal Opinion*

YUI and Ai Otsuka are the type of voices that I hate..
so i gotta vote for Erika..

However, Erika's voice was pretty good at the first few seconds. Once she reached the chorus, i was like "ew"...
ruins the whole song